Roth vs. Traditional Calculator
Compare estimated after-tax outcomes for Roth and traditional retirement contributions, including tax assumptions, growth assumptions, and a retirement withdrawal test.
These tools are built to help you compare retirement account, tax, income, and location decisions. The numbers are not a final answer, but they can help you understand what questions are worth asking next.
Retirement calculators are most useful when you treat them as comparison tools. Instead of looking for one perfect number, use them to test different assumptions: tax rates, withdrawal timing, account type, location, income needs, and retirement age.
The goal is not to predict the future perfectly. The goal is to make the tradeoffs clearer before you make a bigger financial decision.
Start with the decision you are trying to compare. Each tool is built for a rough estimate, not a final planning answer.
Compare estimated after-tax outcomes for Roth and traditional retirement contributions, including tax assumptions, growth assumptions, and a retirement withdrawal test.
Estimate how state income, property, and sales taxes may differ based on your income, home value, and taxable spending assumptions.
Estimate how your earnings history, claiming age, full retirement age, and COLA assumptions may affect your monthly Social Security retirement benefit.
Here is a simple way to choose the right tool.
This calculator is useful when you are thinking about whether it may be better to pay taxes now through Roth contributions or defer taxes through a traditional retirement account.
Go to Roth vs. Traditional →This tool is useful if you are weighing different states and want a rough sense of how income, property, and sales taxes may affect the bigger picture.
Go to State Tax Comparison →This calculator is useful if you want a rough estimate of how earnings history, full retirement age, claiming age, and COLA assumptions may affect your monthly Social Security retirement benefit.
Go to Social Security Benefit →The calculators work best when you understand the planning issue behind the numbers. Pair them with the Tax Planning, Investments, or Retirement guides for more context.
Explore guides →Calculator results depend heavily on the assumptions you enter. A small change in tax rate, return assumption, retirement age, withdrawal need, or location can change the outcome. Use the results as a planning prompt, not as a recommendation.
For major decisions involving taxes, retirement accounts, Social Security, real estate, or investments, consider reviewing the result with a qualified professional.
Calculators can show you the numbers. Guides can help explain why those numbers matter and what tradeoffs may sit behind them.
Explore the guidesSteadyRetire provides educational content only. Calculator results are estimates and should not be treated as individualized financial, investment, tax, or legal advice.